· 5 min read
What is a website design audit, and what should it include?
What a website and product design audit is, what a useful one includes, what it costs, and when to get one instead of a full redesign.
By Nuzair Ibrahim, founder of Pixelary
A design audit is an outside review of how your website and product look and work, ending with a ranked list of what to change. It is the right first step when something feels off and nobody on the team can say what, or when you are about to spend real money on a redesign and want to know which parts are worth keeping.
What should a design audit check?
Every studio has its own list. Whatever the list, it should cover the things buyers notice in the first minute, not only what designers notice:
- The message: whether the headline says who it is for and what changes for them.
- Hierarchy: whether the one thing that matters on each page is the thing people see first.
- Colour and type: whether they have a system and a job, or are defaults.
- Proof: whether reviews, logos and numbers are real and specific.
- Product imagery: whether people can see the actual product.
- Consistency between the site and the product.
- Accessibility: contrast, text size, keyboard use.
- Performance on a phone.
- Whether it looks generated. Twelve common tells are in this checklist.
What should you get at the end?
A report alone is easy to agree with and hard to act on. Look for an audit that ends with a direction you can see: a visual direction for colour and type, and at least one real screen redesigned so your team can compare before and after. Findings should be ranked by impact and effort, so you know what to do on Monday.
Audit or full redesign?
- Get an audit if you are not sure what is wrong, if the site was built recently, or if you need to convince a co-founder or board before spending more.
- Skip straight to a redesign if the site is several years old, the product has changed, and everyone already agrees it needs replacing.
- Often the answer is in between: keep the stack and the structure, replace the parts people notice. An audit tells you which parts those are.
What our Taste Audit includes
Our Taste Audit costs $1,950, paid upfront, and takes one week. You get an audit report across ten checks, a moodboard with a type and colour system, one key screen redesigned in high-fidelity Figma, and a Loom walkthrough of every finding. If you book a build within 30 days, the fee is credited against it. To see what changes when the findings are applied, look at the Evenly case study.